More Switch control ideas...

ModelRailroadForums.com is a free Model Railroad Discussion Forum and photo gallery. We cover all scales and sizes of model railroads. Online since 2002, it's one of the oldest and largest model railroad forums on the web. Whether you're a master model railroader or just getting started, you'll find something of interest here.


jbaakko

Diesel Detail Freak
I can't decide, there's to many options for turnout control.

  • Caboose Industries throws, but the over scale issue is annoying. I might be able to modify them to look like modern hoop handle throws however.
  • Then there's Blue Point machines:
    http://www.ppw-aline.com/Blue Point Manual Turnout Control.htm

    I might use them on the few mainline switches which in reality would be power switches anyways. I'd use manual push-pull throws on the fascia (is that the right word?). This works great on some of the modules, but a few of the switches will be blocked by the lumber framing underneath.
  • Proto:87 stores carries a nice hand throw, though it would require a more complex set-up on the fascia...
    http://www.proto87.com/turnout-controls.html
  • Maybe use a lever from CTC parts, in conjunction with the 90 degree turn part from Proto:87 stores? The CTC lever would push-pull on a rod, connecting to the 90 degree turn part, which would then connect at standard 90 degree angle to the track.
    http://www.ctcparts.com
  • I just read about using a slide switch embedded in the layout, as a sliding switch actuator. Again, this works great, minus the mainline... The rod connects through the plastic slide, when you slide the false stand, which would be connected to the slide switch, it switches the turnout...
  • ANE Model has a nice servo operated switch idea. The cheap kit is $20. This would allow for power switches. Little costly however.

My current thought, is to use modified Caboose throws on the "branchline" switches, and Blue Point machines on the mainline switches. Does this sound viable?
 
I'm using blue points on my entire layout. The main thing i have against about cab. ground throws is that your arm blocks everyones view everytime you switch a turnout.
 
Good thought. The issue I'm having right now, with the blue points, is the space under the layout, I designed the whole layout with Caboose throws in mind, then changed my mind. With some creative cutting of the foam base, I might be able to fit them...
 


On my HO layout I use N-scale Caboose throws.....much less scale issues.

The .135" travel throws? #105R & #206S? I've been looking for those at the LHS, they don't seem to carry them. Are they smaller then the HO scale counterparts? I'll be back down there Monday, after a stop off at Radio Shack.
 
switch controls

I love all those products Josh and I guess thier cheap enough. Maybe you should try the way I did it. It does work well and is very cheap.

NYC_George
 
The .135" travel throws? #105R & #206S? I've been looking for those at the LHS, they don't seem to carry them. Are they smaller then the HO scale counterparts? I'll be back down there Monday, after a stop off at Radio Shack.

not sure which I used in particular, only that it was N scale and has been working just fine. (iirc, it was 105 but it's been about 20 years...) but I know that the throw distance matched very well with what I needed. Perhaps tonight or this weekend I can get a pic on the layout. It may be what I need to get up there.....:eek:
 
Choc-block?

I used a bicycle spoke and choc-block connector for each switch. Total cost was 62cents Canadian per switch

I too am busy trying to decide how to control turnouts on part of the layout. I plan to go manual on that section. Gene, what is a choc-block?
 


JimmyG ...since a pic is worth a thousand words:D


heres a link to a page that shows a choc-bloc strip...1st pic
http://www.tlc-direct.co.uk/Main_Index/Necessities_Index/Connector_Strips/

and heres a drawing, courtesy of the artist, Jack (Shortliner) Trollope, showing how I use them
spokea1.png


i don't bother with the micro-switch.
 
Choc-Blocks

Gene,
Got it! I know what they are now. I didn't know they were called choc-blocks. Thanks much for the info and drawing! :) There certainly are many ways to skin a cat.
 
Jimmy...no problem.
A bit more info...I just glued the choc-blocs to the bottom of my baseboard, and in most cases only needed one block per rod. Also..I used straightened #1 paperclips as the wire thru the baseboard to operate the switch...of course my baseboards aren't very thick:D

Gene
 
N scale Caboose Industries on HO scale layout

Here's some pics from the layout (thanx for the inspiration!).

Notes:
the white dot indicates at a distant glance that it is aligned for the main. The "flip" side has a red dot on a white background.
I used square styrene sized to match the ties as a base. I built the base up until it was at the right level.
 
Last edited by a moderator:




Affiliate Disclosure: We may receive a commision from some of the links and ads shown on this website (Learn More Here)

Back
Top