Can oval layouts bring enough satisfaction?


logandsawman said:
No matter how big your oval is you may always want a bigger one. Spoken from experience.

One advantage with the smaller one is you could actually finish the scenery!

Dave LASM
Click to expand...

Yup, my oval is the better part of a 12'x12' layout to allow for continuous running while the rest of the layout is an effort to create switching opportunities while still allowing room for scenery. I tried to avoid the oval when designing my plan but it always seemed to reduce opportunities for things I valued more so I ended up with an oval. It's all about personal preference and what it is you prioritize.
 
Two ideas:

6000.jpg


6001.jpg
 
My original layout was nothing more than an oval with a couple sidings and a shoebox and some cut down 2x4s as make-believe buildings. Though I was a young kid at the time, my imagination was in its prime.
 
Now there's an excellent example of superelvation on high-speed curves!

Shoeboxes on a "Plywood Pacific" loop are the first steps, but as we get older the imagination requires a little more stimulation, and hopefully one is inspired to add more detail, and some thought as to the function of the layout.
 
Can oval layouts bring enough satisfaction? Yes and no. It depends on what your interests are. If you are into prototypical timetabled (or sequence) operation, then building a layout consisting of one or more ovals of track would be wrong for you. If you want to see a short train ambling along a remote rural branch line, it may or may not work for you, but probably not. However if you love watching trains going around and have no intention of operating a timetable, then it could well be what you need.

I have built a few terminus to yard rural branchline layouts and found each one less interesting than the last, in fact they didn't get anywhere near completion because I just lost interest in them. This was followed by a long break with no modelling other than building the occasional item of rolling stock.

When my interest was rekindled about 7 or 8 years ago, I decided on something a bit different and built a double track continuous run layout on an 8'x4' board. I included a locomotive depot and turntable, a small goods yard, a four track terminus, and a reversing loop, so it's a bit more than a double oval I suppose but basically it's just a means to run one or two trains around and around and due to both that and the cramped nature of the board, it is hardly prototypical. It has also maintained my interest and given me more satisfaction than anything else I have had in the past. And the grandchildren love it too.......

Here it is:

P1010212.jpg
 
One of my favorite stories from building my layout, which started as a basic 4x8, was when I came up from the basement and told my wife, "I just drilled a hole in the wall."
"Why did you do that?"
"Because the railroad had to expand."
"...I was afraid of that."
🤣 🤣 🤣

I have the room and ability to build a larger layout and am enjoying that process. I'll basically just repeat what others have said, though: Start with your 4x8 and see how you like it. You may decide you love it, hate it, like it okay, you may want something more or maybe even less. The point is: Dive in! Give it a start and see how it goes. We would all love to see what you come up with.
 
I'm building my first layout in the garage and I was limited to half the garage to use. Mine is a 5x12 foot layout. Mostly an oval loop, but the length helps make it look less like a loop I think. I also added in some elements to allow for minor switching for doing operations on what will eventually be 3 industries. I like running trains, but I wanted to give myself some operations options also to keep it interesting.
9-8-23 Update 1.jpg


But the main rule is do what is fun for you. Build what you can in the space you have. Eventually I will build my next layout which will likely be different in design, but this one is for learning.

Interested to hear the epilogue to KB02's story about drilling a hole in the wall...like KB02 said give it a try. Always better to build a layout that you want to redo IMHO than just endlessly dreaming what one could do.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.



Back
Top