Weathering Rolling Stock, a Continous thread

ModelRailroadForums.com is a free Model Railroad Discussion Forum and photo gallery. We cover all scales and sizes of model railroads. Online since 2002, it's one of the oldest and largest model railroad forums on the web. Whether you're a master model railroader or just getting started, you'll find something of interest here.


Status
Not open for further replies.
Done a little weathering over the last few days, haven't tried to do much, first one I decided on a new but used look, what do you think ?

View attachment 176285
View attachment 176286

Seeing as this belongs to a leasing company, I reckon they would keep them clean, so I've only done the trucks.

View attachment 176287

I've also managed to get the decals done for the Gon I have, just waiting on the Micro sol, I have the Red one (found it too late to be usefull) waiting on the blue one now, then I can decal and weather it.

The Logo and number I've half-inched from, I think, an Athearn Gondola, but need to work out how to make my own, I can do the lettering, it's getting a separate colour surround I can't figure out.:(

View attachment 176288
I like them. The bottom edging on 209872 is excellent
 


A “less is more” steel boxcar:

IMG_3408.jpeg


This is a new piece, an Atlas double-door 40-ft box car. Did the rust streak at the end of the door slide with a Vallejo burnt umber wash followed by some uncut strength of the same.

Then, added about 1/4 drop of black to that wash, and used it for highliting the corrogations in, and edges of, the doors, & the door tracks, the roof detail, and to grime up the ladder and hand grab areas..

i wanted thus to look a bit newer than my other steel N&W and C&O boxcars, so I decided to forego my normal “100% wipe down” with pastels. Instead, I just went for a couple of darkened streaks, using an approx. 1:1:1 mix of brown, red/orange, and dark gray from the Master’s Touch earth tone pastel set.

To darken up the roof for some good steam era soot and grime, I added to the above pastel mix, some black and the darkest gray, both from Argent Art’s grey pastel assortment.

I also used the same dark pastel mix to dust over and around where I had used the dark wash to highlight ladders and hand

Final detail before sealing with Testor’s Dullcote was a litlle white pastel streaking down from where I had faded the lettering. I didn’t put any directly under the door track, as I figured the continual streaking of rust there would overwhelm the lettering runoff.

Trucks weathered with 1:1 mix of normal brown & dark brown Masters Touch pastels, applied by dipping a brush into 70% isopropyl alcohol, dipping into the pastel mixture, then painting wheel & truck faces. (99% evaporates too quick to paint it on, and plain water takes too long to dry)

Above picture is with flash, which helps highlight the darkness of the grimed-up roof, below is without:

IMG_3402.jpeg


And here is a bit of a look down at the roof:

IMG_3405.jpeg


P.S.: I didn’t wipe the white letter run streak directly below the end of the door track, as I figured the continual streaking rust would always overrun it.
 
Last edited:
Here are a couple of my “100% wipe down” cars for comparison to the above:

IMG_3392.jpeg


IMG_3389.jpeg


Just more grime all around and more rust spots added. The pastel dust gives all of the lettering a “rusting through” look.

I prefer Testor’s Dullcote for base coating and topcoating these steel boxcar red cars. Pastel chalks create really drab areas on the cars, but the Dullcote, and its affinity for absorbing/hiding pastel dust brings back the vividness of the lacquers Atlas uses. I’ve become able to compensate for how much Dullcote dimishes the effect of chalks.

For that matter, if I need a steel boxcar in a boxcar red, I pretty much look exclusively for an Atlas - no other brand’s finish gives me the look that I want. Conversely, for a wood boxcar I’ll go 100% with MicroTrains, because they more naturally yield the finished look I want there.

You may notice and remark that I haven’t done much (ok, not any) fading of the main body color. Well, you’re right- and I’ve looked over the C&O Historical Society photographic archives, and the lettering fades, but the body color stays pretty dark.

Here for your viewing pleasure (and perhaps some amusement and amazement) is some “extreme weathering” from the archive (albeit another railroad shown in the photo) showing this:

IMG_3400.png


P.S.: Note to self: Notice how very large letters can have independent left and right paint dust streaks.
 
Last edited:
Here are a couple of my “100% wipe down” cars for comparison to the above:

View attachment 176437

View attachment 176438

Just more grime all around and more rust spots added. The pastel dust gives all of the lettering a “rusting through” look.

I prefer Testor’s Dullcote for base coating and topcoating these steel boxcar red cars. Pastel chalks create really drab areas on the cars, but the Dullcote, and its affinity for absorbing/hiding pastel dust brings back the vividness of the lacquers Atlas uses. I’ve become able to compensate for how much Dullcote dimishes the effect of chalks.

For that matter, if I need a steel boxcar in a boxcar red, I pretty much look exclusively for an Atlas - no other brand’s finish gives me the look that I want. Conversely, for a wood boxcar I’ll go 100% with MicroTrains, because they more naturally yield the finished look I want there.

You may notice and remark that I haven’t done much (ok, not any) fading of the main body color. Well, you’re right- and I’ve looked over the C&O Historical Society photographic archives, and the lettering fades, but the body color stays pretty dark.

Here for your viewing pleasure (and perhaps some amusement and amazement) is some “extreme weathering” from the archive (albeit another railroad shown in the photo) showing this:

View attachment 176439

P.S.: Note to self: Notice how very large letters can have independent left and right paint dust streaks.
I really like both cars. Nicely weathered but not overboard.

I can’t handle Testors dull cote after using it for literally decades! During Covid the smell just really got to me. I loved using Pan Pastels but disliked the Dull cote diminishing the coverage. When I use Pan Pastels I now use the VMS- matte clear varnish which IMOO is less aggressive to the Pan Pastels

That third car, I’d like to duplicate that. Wow
 
I really like both cars. Nicely weathered but not overboard.

I can’t handle Testors dull cote after using it for literally decades! During Covid the smell just really got to me. I loved using Pan Pastels but disliked the Dull cote diminishing the coverage. When I use Pan Pastels I now use the VMS- matte clear varnish which IMOO is less aggressive to the Pan Pastels

That third car, I’d like to duplicate that. Wow

Yeah, there’s a balance that Dullcote strikes for me in certain situations:

When I do the white lettering deterioration runs, it’s difficult for me to not overdo it, and to me that’s among the uglier mistakes I make. And I am a poor hand still yet at determining whether I’ve overdone it or not, with the car in progress. So, I’ll generally Dullcote a car that I do lettering runs/streaks, as it’s a measure of “insurance” against overdoing.

Those last two batches of hoppers I did and reported in previous posts had no letter fades, and I wanted all my chalk work to show through, so Vallejo Matte Varnish was the choice.

Those wood box cars I “remediated” (also in a previous post) - the original seal was Dullcote, to keep the letter streaks understated. Then, when I gave the cars a good fade a few months later, the topcoat was the Vallejo Matte Varnish, because all I had added was a fade layer over the old work.

For me, as far as smells go, I have the liberty of taking spray painting outdoors, weather & daylight permitting (both becoming rarer at this time of year), because I live in a rural area.
 
Last edited:
IMG_1933.jpeg
IMG_1934.jpeg
IMG_1935.jpeg
IMG_1936.jpeg
IMG_1937.jpeg
IMG_1938.jpeg
IMG_1939.jpeg
IMG_1940.jpeg
The last of my ScaleTrain Bulkhead flats went out the door yesterday. I packaged it up prior to leaving for Texas. Decided yesterday during some downtime at the golf course to see if it would sell on FB and it did. The daughter took it to the post office for me

The same reporting marks as the previous car but a different deck finish
 
These were the next cars up for weathering when I headed out on Wednesday
IMG_4935.jpeg


3 Private road name cars from Accurail. I had a great discussion with the cars owner and I have some ideas and have sent some pictures of similar prototype type cars. He definitely wants the letters faded but still wants them readable

Build dates are 1969 and he sort of models to fit 1990 to 2005

I am in another weather delay on the golf course, another batch of rainy fog! So going through my phone
 


Another car started for me but my stuff takes a back seat to weathering commissions. Another private road name car that I have shown the start of a couple weeks ago. Pilar Valley Railway available via HomeShops.net from Tangent models
IMG_1953.jpeg
IMG_1952.jpeg


2 sides maybe done. I included the end panel shots to give you an indication of the transformation
IMG_1954.jpeg
IMG_1955.jpeg


The ends are also done but I guess I took no photos. Hopefully this car is completed before Thanksgiving. The difference in the amount of weathering on each side is purposeful. Not all the car sides weather and age the same

As for graffiti and tags for this car, at this time I am leaning to no!
 
IMG_1974.jpeg
IMG_1975.jpeg
IMG_1976.jpeg
IMG_1977.jpeg
IMG_1979.jpeg
IMG_1980.jpeg
IMG_1981.jpeg
IMG_1982.jpeg
IMG_1983.jpeg
I had hoped I would never do another Walthers Mainline yellow TBOX 60’ high cube boxcar let alone 4 more. Lightly weathered and a couple may actually reach medium but no graffiti. Originally done per a client request. These are out on FB for sale. Built between 1/2011 and 1/2012 in Mexico. $44 each and if you use the forum email I will include shipping
 


That’s what I like, subtle weathering and no shine.
Nice!
Thank you. I’ve done many of these cars this way. If you look on YouTube train graffiti videos most of these cars are covered in graffiti. Similar to the white canvas that the ARMN reefers provide to graffiti artists/vandals. Yellow seems to draw (pun intended) these guys out. It was a nice change to do some cars without graffiti
 
Status
Not open for further replies.




Affiliate Disclosure: We may receive a commision from some of the links and ads shown on this website (Learn More Here)

Back
Top