I could have this completely wrong, but my understanding of having a high resolution photo is: when reduced to a smaller size photo, there is more photo information (pixels) available for the reduction than you would if using a lower resolution, providing you with a sharper image. The lower doesn't have it "all" to begin with, giving you a lesser quality photo. I may be in left field on this, but I can certainly tell the difference even on a forum. As an example, look at some of Eric's (Grande Man) compared to others. While all are good, Eric's has a much sharper image. What is good'nuf?...well, isn't that an individual's opinion.
Your correct in what you said above Rex, the greater the Pixels count of the cameras sensor* the greater the image quality will be, especially when reduced in size as is needed in most cases to post an image on the forum. [*] Different cameras use different size sensors and the smaller the sensor the less the pixel count count is. That is the reason some of the better Canons even use full frame 35mm size sensors to retain more image data hence an image that can be expanded more and retain the clarity of detail required.
As you also stated, the higher the resolution an image is photographed at
the more information is available when that image is reduced. Now there is a point at which each photographer has to determine just what is enough, in his opinion, from the standpoint of pixel count & image quality to give him an image that is suitable for the job at hand. Along with this is just how much storage space and time is he willing to devote to any given image for the purpose it's being used for? While most images we put on the forum here are of very decent quality most were not shot with the idea of being used for a magazine advertisement and hence, at least in my case I don't try to shoot at an very high pixel count for that reason. That is also the reason why the forum needs to limit file size so images will load fairly readly as compared to taking a considerable length of time due to hugh file sizes such as can be encountered with high pixel count images. I shoot at a fairly moderate pixel count of 3.5Mp which produces an image of 2304 x 1536 pixels and generally reduce this down to 905 x 603 so it is acceptable for downloading to the forum as well as not taking up a lot of file size on my system.
Of course the lens quality and focal length also certainly has something to do with image quality as does lighting to some extent. I'll have to admit I get a bit lazy and generally leave my 28-105 lens on the camera body as it gives a more normal perspective to the images with fairly decent clarity and I most often trip the shutter using my finger to live a bit dangerously but sometimes it's necessary too.
Regardless of differing opinions, I am getting a lot out of this thread and I hope to continue getting advice and opinions from those out there that know. I think by covering all areas of a camera, manual and auto operation, is important since not all auto settings fit all situations.
That too is very correct Rex, as to get the shot you or I want, depth of field is often an important issue and in most cases needs to be adjusted to through the focus onto the main subject of interest while allowing enough depth as we feel necessary for the rest of the shot. That's why, like Eric brought up, shooting in Aperture priority is required to accomplish this. Also, while a Wide Angle lens will give the greatest depth of field it's fairly hard to control getting too much background due to that fact too.
Many times, with my old 'point and shoot camera', I just couldn't get what I wanted in Auto. Even though it had limited manual adjustments, I didn't really understand what the "H" I was doing. Now and with my Canon T2i, I hope that I will not be restricted to only certain types of shooting opportunities. All of this is relative to the original poster and with his permission, I hope you will keep it coming in.
There's nothing like being able to control the various aspects of the image your trying to create.
Good shooting and look forward to seeing what your coming up with.