As long as people are not personally rude I think a robust argument standing up for what you like is okay, I use peco 70 and have run foul of the modellers who use more expensive ‘more accurate’ track, but if you do the math and my other half did they also have flaws sone flaws the peco 7o does not have,building you own is an option….if you have a machine shop,an immense amount of time,and a team or a not too large layout but we have almost 44 foot twice and 4 feet deep plus track in a second loft,Peco 70 is easy to shape fits well and does me nicely for old and new stock bogies, so if I post on forums that strive for “excellence” then when they ask about my track then bemoan it, I smile nicely let them have their say and say I do not have the time to do it on my layout, end of, polite but firm,not apologising,and 9/10 times I look at the work of these excellent modellers they either have a super tiny layout to exacting standards but basically nothing to play with,or my work is still better than theirs overall. if people are so small they have to knock others it says more about them than it says about the person being knocked.
We all make personal choices,why we do something,or don’t do something, and that is what they are, now if a person asks for advice on improving something and they say a specific area or a general go for it,we’ll then if people wade in they get the good and the bad,but they still get to choose what THEY~ wish to uptake, and not be bullied by others.
I look at the likes of santafewillies layout and am gobsmacked, how he gets so much in,and done,and time to share, and like any large modellers some areas are more advanced than others,one person is likely to struggle to get everything up to top notch, I have tonnes of areas that are half done,part started,not yet fit for photographing, awaiting me to get off my butt and sort them….examples of part started then basically abandoned work as I do something else,and the last two years I have basically done very very little most of what you see is old work,as my working day is about animals,garden,and other hobbies,plus general cooking cleaning washing.
This is St Margarets named after my mil.
Who loved to shop. I can can squeeze so close up, a small station is at the rear near the car park,with 2 tracks leaving this loft to go to the other,and it sits over the top of 9 tracks that act as storage for non running rolling stock,I have carved the road to the pavements and coloured,but no lamps no road markings it is pretty much abandoned as it is not able to reference real life photographs which I concentrate on more,but I will get to it….eventually.
My personal opinion is do not be the first person to throw stones,chances are you do live in a glass house and deserves to get them lobbed back, pith helmet essential!
View attachment 138231View attachment 138232View attachment 138233View attachment 138234View attachment 138235View attachment 138236View attachment 138237View attachment 138238View attachment 138239View attachment 138240
And do not forget except for the odd structure being weathered, these are bought in a box as you see no construction required,so not time input.just cash investment. And yet people will rave over them,for me personally I like them, BUT if I had the time I prefer a kit bashed or scratch build every time.
edited…oh and it is going to be a typical market town on market day the car park will double with the stalls. The stalls will have to be kit or homemade,I know what I plan and can make them fairly easily have bought a couple of stalls to evaluate, but time is the kicker.