If strictly modelling, the gentleman above is quite right, and you should look around, or get colour photos. Otherwise, cement looks pretty much the same, albeit with weathering it can look grey, gravelly, rusty, blackened with soot.....
I mix a medium grey, add fair bit of pure white, a half drop of yellow, and some burnt umber, maybe a full dollop squeezed out of one of those small plastic bottles from Wally's. Mix it thoroughly, dilute it with another 50% water, and then try a first coat on the plaster or hydrocal (hyrdrocal doesn't paint well, so I hope you are using plaster or drywall mud, or something other than hydrocal). Let that first coat dry, and live with it for a full day. Hate it? Figure out what is wrong, and correct by adding a fully dollop of the appropriate colour of acrylic paint...probably more white and umber, but you'll figure it out. Same thing, one coat, let it dry, and live with it. Keep doing this until you know you are really close. Really close is good enough, because your weathering will close the gap much more. Label the bottle you keep this concoction in, and seal it well.
-Crandell