when do i use....
- Thread starter brubakes
- Start date
Selector
Well-Known Member
Tough call...although it comes down to what will run through either one reliably without causing shorts or without running out of contact and stalling on the insulated length.
Generally, an insulated frog reduces the potential to short axles across differently polarized rails in proximity to the frog. But that means the item needing power must have powered axles spread far enough apart that when one is just leaving the dead frog the rear one is still on powered track, thus keeping the motor/decoder supplied with electricity. If you run longer diesels or steamers, especially ones made in the past 10-15 years, chances are excellent that insulfrog is the safer way to go, particularly with the shorts-sensitive DCC systems. If you are running small switchers, then you may have to power your frogs using toggles and jumpers, or you'll have to use electro-frog turnouts that route the power for you.
Generally, an insulated frog reduces the potential to short axles across differently polarized rails in proximity to the frog. But that means the item needing power must have powered axles spread far enough apart that when one is just leaving the dead frog the rear one is still on powered track, thus keeping the motor/decoder supplied with electricity. If you run longer diesels or steamers, especially ones made in the past 10-15 years, chances are excellent that insulfrog is the safer way to go, particularly with the shorts-sensitive DCC systems. If you are running small switchers, then you may have to power your frogs using toggles and jumpers, or you'll have to use electro-frog turnouts that route the power for you.
brubakes
Member
Is Electrofrog a term used on with Peco products or is that a term industry wide?
SpaceMouse
Fun Lover
I think it's kinda like the word Xerox.
brubakes
Member
And Kleenex and Scotch Tape. I did a search on Walthers site and only Peco products were returned with "Electrofrog".
Electrofrog and Insulfrog are actually trademarks owned by Peco although they are starting to take on a generic meaning. At some point, Peco's lawyers will probably go after MR or some other publication that doesn't use the term in caps and with the little TM after it. Better terms all the way around would be a powered frog and a non-powered frog turnout, since this conveys the exact meaning of what we're wrtiting about.
