Used vs new

ModelRailroadForums.com is a free Model Railroad Discussion Forum and photo gallery. We cover all scales and sizes of model railroads. Online since 2002, it's one of the oldest and largest model railroad forums on the web. Whether you're a master model railroader or just getting started, you'll find something of interest here.


yaakman

New Member
I am still in the research mode of getting into model railroading and need more advice. I am considering buying a 70s vintage layout which includes lots of track several locomotives and cars and misc other items.
My questions are. Is there any disadvantage of buying old equipment? Will the old track work with new track if I want to expand? The setup is all DC does that matter? What can one reasonably expect to pay for a setup like this? Any advice would be greatly appreciated.
 
I am still in the research mode of getting into model railroading and need more advice. I am considering buying a 70s vintage layout which includes lots of track several locomotives and cars and misc other items.
My questions are. Is there any disadvantage of buying old equipment? Will the old track work with new track if I want to expand? The setup is all DC does that matter? What can one reasonably expect to pay for a setup like this? Any advice would be greatly appreciated.

Short answer to all--it depends. Im assuming were talking HO here. With that in mind, track has changed somewhat. It used to be brass code 100 (taller rail, black ties), but most of it is now nickel silver and Code 83 (shorter rail height , brown or concrete and more prototypica) has emerged as a favorite. the reason being is that brass oxidizes more readily and the oxidation hinders electrical conductivity whereas the nickel silver is more resistant to it.

Either way, you can expand old track to new track as there are transition joiners that will allow you to attach the two together.

Also, track is easily replaceable and new, good quality track is relatively inexpensive. So if you need/want to replace the old stuff or not buy it at all, it wouldnt be that expensive to do. Turnouts and specialty pieces like crossings are more expensive, but rolling stock/locomotives is really where imho the hobby gets pricey.

Doesnt matter that its DC. You can easily go DCC with it if you want later.

Older equipment can be gems or it can be junk. Probably all of it will need a good cleaning/tuneup. It may be a bit harder to convert some of it to DCC later or not worth it.

Price--hard to say. Depends largely upon the size of the collection, its condition, and its make and model. If you show up and see alot of brass track and Tyco, LifeLike, Model Power, and Bachmann--your looking at low end stuff (train set quality). If you see alot of Athearn, Walthers, Kato--your looking at higher quality trains. If its brass trains, prepare to pay thru the nose.
 
BigB has covered most of the considerations. Time and waning interest if the results don't come thick and fast, are major issues. It will take time, and some patience, creative solutions, waiting for replacement parts, or shopping endlessly for them if you can't make your own, and then all the manual skill it will take to disassemble things without catastrophic results, fixing, and then reassembling them.

Cost, too is going to be an issue. Are the flanges on the wheels were dealing with close to, or in compliance with the NMRA RP-25 profile? If they are deeper flanges, you must convert them, swap them out for newer wheel sets that may fit (with more 'adjustments' to the frames...more time and patience and determination), or just live with them as they are.

One thing to consider as well...it happened to me. I entered the hobby and loved all the learning, the history, the execution of newly acquired skills, and then playing with all the best locomotives and stock one could have this side of brass prices. But suddenly I wanted others to see what I had done, and I engaged in photography. Suddenly, it was almost more about the imagery since the modeling had largely been accomplished. My point is that the older equipment is likely to look dated...especially highly visible things, noticeable things, like deep pizza-cutter flanges.

If these things have sentimental value, or if they don't but you don't mind the projects, and can stand the outlay of cash to acquire the things you'll need to repair/restore these items so that they are fun for you, then by all means seize this opportunity. Even many of the boxcars and other rolling stock can be used, I'm sure. But engines are a whole nuther catfish.

Crandell
 




Affiliate Disclosure: We may receive a commision from some of the links and ads shown on this website (Learn More Here)

Back
Top