ModelRailroadForums.com is a free
Model Railroad Discussion Forum and
photo gallery. We cover all scales and sizes of model railroads. Online since 2002, it's one of the oldest and largest model railroad forums on the web. Whether you're a master model railroader or just getting started, you'll find something of interest here.
I recently purchased two Kadee boxcars. The coupler is, I believe, the 58. I would prefer the 5 just for consistency with the rest of my rolling stock. Can the coupler be switched? A brief look makes it seem difficult to open things up. (Yes, I am a newbie.)
Thanks!
BTW:
I have converted nearly all of my stock to Kadee. The #4 defeats me as I just can't cope with those springs. They interlock and I can't separate them. Then they keep trying to escape.
The 'whisker' ones (148?) are really nice.
Other than getting height adjusted and screwing up one Bachman truck putting in a 27, it has gone well. Remembering to remove the gauge from the track is probably my most consistent problem.
I don't think it's really worth the effort to change from a #5 to a #58 just for consistency. There's very little difference between the two except for the #58 being slightly smaller so it's more scale looking. They will work fine with #5's and I don't see the point of chucking two good pairs of #5's when they will just be a little bigger than your #58's.
If you really want to change the couplers anyway, the top cover should be held on by a screw. Just unscrew it and change out the existing #5's to #58's.
Jim, I think he meant the other way around, but I 2nd the thought, its a waste to replace a good coupler.
I don't like it either, but the 58s don't seem to work as well with the 5s. They don't couple as well as the 5s. (Yes, I would swap out the 58, and install the 5.)
As for the screw, I wish it was that simple. They seem to have sealed it up pretty well.
Maybe I just need to learn to live with it.
Josh, you're right, mind was going in the opposite direction.
Fazby, I don't have a Kadee boxcar here to check how the coupler is secured but the ones I've seen either have a screw at the coupler pocket or you have to take off both trucks and drop the center sill to access the couplers. Maybe someone else with a Kadee box car can give you the correct method or, failing that, e-mail Kadee. I have a mix of #5's and #58's and the #58's are more finiky about the coupler being mounted at just the right height. Using your coupler heign gauge, check the height of the #58's as given at the Kadee web site. If that height is correct, I suspect the problem is not the #58's but that you've got some #5's mounted too low and they need to be shimmed. See which cars aren't working well with the #58's and I think you'll find a problem with the #5's. This is what I had to go through with my mix and a lot of #5's I thought were fine were either a little high or a little low. As a result of getting the #58's and adjusting the #5's, I rarely have a coupler problem anymore.
Thanks for the thoughts. I will take a closer look at the boxcar construction.
The 58s are probably just fine and I need to tweak something. A fresh application of 'grease 'em' can do wonders. The issue I have had is that they don't want to couple all that readily.
I will keep learning - I am probably going off half-cocked. Thanks for your patience with a beginner.
Affiliate Disclosure: We may receive a commision from some of the links and ads shown on this website
(Learn More Here)
