ModelRailroadForums.com is a free
Model Railroad Discussion Forum and
photo gallery. We cover all scales and sizes of model railroads. Online since 2002, it's one of the oldest and largest model railroad forums on the web. Whether you're a master model railroader or just getting started, you'll find something of interest here.
How many of the Forum Members used track plans from a magazine or book, designed your own track plan or processed ahead with just a track plan in mind? If you designed your own track plan did you use a track planning software or drew the plan free hand? If you used a track planning software, which one did you use?
Thanks everyone.
Greg
I had a general plan in mind, and sketched the benchwork first, to make sure it would all fit and that I bought enough lumber. From there I just laid track using a set of home made curvature templates and a straightedge to assure that I was not fudging things. Occasionally I sketched out not to scale drawings of switching areas and continued to just lay track. This I did more to remember from one weekend to the next what I had planned. After retirement, that wasn't quite as necessary as I worked on it day to day. Of my 70+ industries to switch, I ended up with only one where I didn't quite give myself enough clearance to the backdrop. I had to move it about 1" closer to the switch. It's an angled siding and I might eventually just remove part of the loading dock and awning (on a non-visible side) and position it back where I wanted it.
I had built three previous layouts (practice I called them) in a different location and pretty much knew what would work and what would not work. Through it all, John Armstrong's book "Track Planning for Realistic Operations" was at my side.
I modified a track plan from Model Railroader's online DB.
I did not follow any specific plan from any source but designed one on Anyrail that is a freestanding walk around that fit the room and had the goals I was looking to achieve in the space I had.
I used SCARM to create the plan, worked pretty well. It has it's kinks but their easy to workaround and the end result is very usable. For creating the track plan, I did a google image search of layouts and found the overall shape that I thought would satisfy my needs. At this point, I'm easy to please so there wasn't much searching. It would likely have been easier to pick a layout from a book/magazine, but that's too easy and leaves too little room for error...

I freelance them on napkins; many many napkins
I use Any Rail 6.3. It’s easy to use and so much fun that I sometimes just play around with it.
I used
XTrackCAD to design my layout. It's very accurate ... and free.
I generally sketch things around on pieces of paper, and do a lot of the final detail design full size on the benchwork. Never have mastered using any of the free track design softwares and haven't wanted to spend the bucks for a more sophisticated one.
Affiliate Disclosure: We may receive a commision from some of the links and ads shown on this website
(Learn More Here)