I thought your old one looked pretty cool. It depends on who is the critic. Some of the stuff I thought was unacceptable, my wife really liked. And her friends. Everyone has a different set of eyes.
I tore apart an old sawmill building, and later regretted it, after looking with a different set of eyes. It was carefully framed authentically like a real one and sheeted with tin foil, which I painted with hand mixed paint and brush to create a streaked effect. Skylights and a huge sliding door. I didn't think it was authentic enough, but I was being too picky. The eye is only going to take in so much stuff.
Anyway, get some paint on this one and put it in the background, at the very least. Someone may see it as exceptional!
No matter what, you are a pro!
lasm