ModelRailroadForums.com is a free
Model Railroad Discussion Forum and
photo gallery. We cover all scales and sizes of model railroads. Online since 2002, it's one of the oldest and largest model railroad forums on the web. Whether you're a master model railroader or just getting started, you'll find something of interest here.
The anticipation builds. These all metal sets are as scarce as hens teeth anywhere and the pre-orders with Bowser are naturally delayed. For how long, who knows. They are great running cars though. They hold the track very well when running in long trains of empties compared to the competitors extremely light weight, all plastics sets.
Well-Known Member
Staff member
Spine cars with real mettle, eh!
Well-Known Member
Staff member
Spine cars with real mettle, eh!
Someone was goin' to say it. Might as well be me. Get it over and done with.
Oh we all knew it would be you Toot, it really was just a matter of time!
I expect once these are released Feebay will be flooded with the older versions.
I have a surplus Walthers set that may end up there.
Well-Known Member
Staff member
Oh we all knew it would be you Toot, it really was just a matter of time!
I expect once these are released Feebay will be flooded with the older versions.
I have a surplus Walthers set that may end up there.
I had a 5 car set at one time too, and the weight, even loaded with trailers, was always an issue. Being solid, I would think, would make a lot of difference. (I'll avoid any reference to the structural component, probably start me off again)
I prefer the metal cars because the light plastic ones don't work out to well in mile long trains.
Wasn't there a way to add weight to these cars? I think I have a set that someone did this to,...but still in my storage trailer waiting for a layout to run on.
Well-Known Member
Staff member
I prefer the metal cars because the light plastic ones don't work out to well in mile long trains.
With the much higher propensity to run longer trains on bigger layouts, then the risk of stringlining cars around curves has increased. Extra weight over and above the NMRA standard does help, but is a difficult balance between helping and hindering, because it will also increase the drag load where there are grades to pull them up before the curves. There's a long section of track on the club layout that I've nicknamed "the slingshot", because it drops down from the highest point, to a 180deg curve that's as low or even a bit lower than the main fiddle yard and then climbs back up again at the same grade, till about half way up and then lessens to point between that low and the high (about 1/2 way) before once again rounding a 90deg back the other way and crossing over to the other side of the layout.
I've run trains that have covered that entire length and more by using helpers in the middle. There's a speed that has to be reached and maintained so that the rear section's weight can push down grade while the front is going upgrade, without derailing the cars in that 180deg turn. Hence the nickname. Could almost do with some of the sophisticated load to speed/power control I'm sure the prototype uses. I found a tail end helper upset things. The mid train ones though were essential to control that down ward push as they were to pull the weight behind them. There would always be 1 less loco in the middle than up front. All 6 axle Genesis locos with similar drives and decoders.
Athearn made some nice Trinity 57' spine cars but never ran them again. Looks like I'll be getting some Bowser cars.
Affiliate Disclosure: We may receive a commision from some of the links and ads shown on this website
(Learn More Here)