MikeGTW
Signalman, ESQ
Just want to say there was no pylon racing NOT allowed pilots doing so could and would be grounded And I'm pretty sure the P-63 does not have electric flap control (might be wrong on that ) What the P-63 pilot did and I saw it on one of the videos He went belly up to the leader and that is a big no-no Found a couple things and I'm going to contact a friend that is on the board of Commemorative Air Force and see if he will tell me anything Probably not since under investigationNo, B-17's don't race anything, and if I suggested that somehow, my bad. Give a B-17 a three minute head start and it would still lose an air race against three WWII fighters...and lose it in the first three feet. I meant the possibility that the three fighters might have been racing one another, and the outer two had bled off speed, and, unfortunately, had widened their turns. With disastrous consequences for the outermost of the three, and for the crew of the B-17.
The reason I was pondering this possibily was because I had seen a configuration like that at an airshow many years ago. All of us, the spectators, were on the south side of the fence looking north across the east-west runway (which presumably accounted for one of the two long pattern legs--the other paralleling the runway again, but behind us to the south), and beyond that a small valley running west-to-east, and a bit further still to the north. The ridge behind that was high, but to the west end it dropped down a bit...which is where the pack of fighters showed up again before the last pylon.
The fighter race that day ran through this little valley, parallel to the runway pattern, the pack of fighters moving flat out--full throttle from west to east. After they passed us by, they ran off east about eight miles to "first" pylon, then north around (the invisible--hidden over the crest of the ridge) pylon number two, and then back SSW to round pylon number three. As they came visible again about two miles off from behind the ridge, and before they reached pylon #3, they were flying across our view (moving R to L), then they rounded the last pylon and came toward the spectators before pulling still further around to pass us by about...1/4 of a mile away or a bit more. So they ran hard around the third pylon, full left bank--4G turns or more in all cases--and coming toward us and then continued further around their turns to pass in front of us moving from our L-to-R. Sooo...as they passed us, they were paralleling the runway, but only about 1/8th of a mile off the runway traffic pattern to the north. A quarter of a mile from us.
They kept well away from one another, and the stragglers were furthest out and away from the pylons. Meaning...closer to us, but also moving slower, as they had dropped out and been left behind. But they had also separated from the faster planes above and inside them too. So they were the closest to us...but they were, therefore, also closest to the runway pattern loop too. Whether running the same direction or opposite to one another.
In Texas, that might have brought the "outer loop" fighters just too close to the planes flying a traffic loop outside them. In this case the B-17.
So, and having seen it organized that way myself, I do have to wonder if the three fighters, all three inside the flightpath of the B-17 were finishing or had just finished such a pylon race. As with the way the traffic lanes were organized thirty years back was that it had the racers INSIDE the outer loop traffic, and that's almost what I see here.
Which leads to the following conclusion: In this case, and for whatever reasons, the converging aircraft were at, or too close to the same altitude for safety's sake. I know it will all be part of many reviews yet to come, so I'll wonder until I hear more, I suppose.
---------------
Further developments: It seems someone on the local control VFR airspace radio net network told/ordered the P-63 pilot to pass ahead of the B-17. Presumably this voice would be that of the "Air Boss," also known as the flight show controller. So the fighter pilot knew the B-17 was there, but, and until it showed up so suddenly from underneath (big blindspot below on the P-63 Kingcobra, I'm hearing), he may not have been sure whether he had already passed ahead of it, or would need to throttle up to do it...until the bomber suddenly showed up as large as life, coming up from that blind spot underneath.
Another of the clips shows what is, to my mind, a very subtle interruption in the fighter's flight path. Was he throttling up to avoid the collision? Or throttling back down...fast? Was he trying to dump airspeed by bringing in the flaps as quickly as he could? We'll never really know, but I don't buy the "suicide" theory some [*elsewhere. Not here*] have speculated about for even one moment.
I can see the fighter pilot instinctively pull back on the stick, to yank his aircraft back up and away from the bomber, only to have it mush out in a high-speed stall. I can see him--in a mere instant--think about and then discard the idea of diving below the B-17 because he wouldn't have had enough altitude after the dive to pull back up and avoid the ground. So many possibilities, a very short time to decide, and almost all of the choices bad...at best....
Anyway here's the schedule for Saturday no pylon race
SATURDAY
9 a.m. Gates open
9 a.m. – 9:45 a.m. Veterans Voices
* Bob Davenport (B-29 Radioman)
* Dan Ragan (B-17 Texas Raiders Veteran)
9:45 a.m. New CAF Member Swearing-In Ceremony on the Flightline
10 a.m. – 10:45 a.m. Veterans Voices Interviews on the Flightline
* David Hamilton (D-Day Pathfinder Pilot)
* Connie Palacioz (B-29 Rosie the Riveter)
10:50 a.m. National Anthem by the Ladies for Liberty
11 a.m. – 2:30 p.m. Flying Demonstrations
* Trainers on Parade
* TORA TORA TORA with B-17 Flying Fortress
* Twisted Texas Airshows
* T-6 Formation Passes
* Air Transport Command Demo (C-45s and C-47s)
* Trojan Phlyers Acro (T-28s)
* Doolittle Raid Demo (B-25 Mitchells)
* Bomber Parade (B-24, B-17, B-25s, A-26)
* Fighter Escorts (SB2C, P-63, P-51s)
* The War Ends (B-29 Superfortress)
* Fighter Power Acro (P-63, P-51 Mustang)
* The War Ends (B-29 Superfortress)
* Missing Man Formation (SB2C, P-51, P-51, P-63)
2:30 p.m. – 3 p.m. Ground Forces Demonstration
3 p.m. Aviation Discovery Zone Closes
and a quote saying what I saw
Arthur Alan Wolk is a Philadelphia aviation attorney who flew in air shows for 12 years. After watching the air show video and hearing the maneuvers described as "bombers on parade," Wolk told The Associated Press Sunday that the P-63 pilot violated the basic rule of formation flying.
"He went belly up to the leader," Wolk said. "That prevents him from gauging distance and position. The risk of collision is very high when you cannot see who you are supposed to be in formation with and that kind of join up is not permitted."
video watch at 30 sec mark he was belly up to the B-17 so could not see him
