chadbag
Well-Known Member
Then you add in the "mandatory tip" thing, and it's no longer a tip in my mind; it's part of the price of the meal. That mechanism is flat out fraud as far as I'm concerned; they're putting a meal price on the menu that's 18% or however much lower than the actual price. It should be illegal; they should have to give alternate menus to large groups or whatever that include the correct prices instead of sneaking it in at the end.
My policy is to tip good service somewhere between 20-25%. What I do is to take the pre-tax price and take 20%. Then I round up to the nearest dollar. And then I sometimes add in a buck or two to that, depending on service and what the total bill was.
IF the company has mandatory service charge, which is normally around 18%, then that's it. I don't add another tip to it. At all. They chose and they chose wrong.
For those who spread tips out over all staff, the actual server should get a minus of 50% of the tip, of not 75%, and the rest spread to the other staff. I know when we first got married and my wife was not yet licensed in the US as a nurse, she worked as a waitress at a sushi / japanese restaurant* and her tips were what we lived off of. Luckily sushi is expensive and they sold a lot of alcohol so tips were pretty good. But even though they had to wait the people who actually sat at the sushi bar, IIRC all the sushi bar tips went to the sushi chefs. They only got the tips, which were grouped together and shared, from the customers who sat at the tables in the restaurant. It was still not a bad income but seemed a bit unfair to me. But since then I've always tried to be a reasonable tipper.
In most cases I refuse to tip at cafeteria style fast casual, and any place that is not sit down service. Occasionally, in the cafeteria style where they make your burrito or whatever as you walk down the aisle, if they're pleasant and have no problem with my "special requests" and stuff and do a good job, I'll add 41 tip or something on the machine. Otherwise I hit "no tip" at places like that. Those place around here pay the line workers and kitchen staff far more than minimum wage. Tips are for good service by the wait staff who get paid the stupid $2.xx / hour wait staff minimum.
* as one of the only actual japanese -- only the head sushi chef was Japanese otherwise. The owner was Taiwanese and the main managers were Taiwanese, the head non sushi chef was Mexican (he had a japanese girlfriend and could could japanese very well), and the rest of the kitchen staff were mainland Chinese, and the rest of the waitresses were "asian". Didn't matter what so they had Chinese/Taiwanese, SE Asian like Vietnam, etc. All Look Same. (alllooksame.com)
