Loco motor "dead spot"?

ModelRailroadForums.com is a free Model Railroad Discussion Forum and photo gallery. We cover all scales and sizes of model railroads. Online since 2002, it's one of the oldest and largest model railroad forums on the web. Whether you're a master model railroader or just getting started, you'll find something of interest here.


John_AP&W

New Member
I just got a "vintage" Atlas S4 (DC only, their item #8285), and am having trouble getting it to run.

Followed Atlas shell-removal instructions. No decoder, just the original light "board"...

When DC is applied, the light comes on, but the motor won't turn UNTIL I give the armature a slight nudge with a small wooden toothpick.
Then it runs fine, and smoothly! As long as I don't shut off the power, it's just great!

After power is turned down, I'm back to no movement until the armature is turned a bit.

When powered down, the armature seems to ALWAYS like to come to rest at this "dead spot". I have yet to get it to stop at any other point.

I presume this has something to do with the brushes and commutator plates, but before I attempt to dig deeper, I thought I'd ask for input from the community...

What's the cause? What's the fix?

Thanks in advance for your constructive comments!
-John
 
You probably have a bad winding or open at the commutator.
The fix is to replae the motor, or return for exchange or refund if it's still in the return/repair window.
 
I just got a "vintage" Atlas S4 (DC only, their item #8285), and am having trouble getting it to run.

Followed Atlas shell-removal instructions. No decoder, just the original light "board"...

When DC is applied, the light comes on, but the motor won't turn UNTIL I give the armature a slight nudge with a small wooden toothpick.
Then it runs fine, and smoothly! As long as I don't shut off the power, it's just great!

After power is turned down, I'm back to no movement until the armature is turned a bit.

When powered down, the armature seems to ALWAYS like to come to rest at this "dead spot". I have yet to get it to stop at any other point.

I presume this has something to do with the brushes and commutator plates, but before I attempt to dig deeper, I thought I'd ask for input from the community...

What's the cause? What's the fix?

Thanks in advance for your constructive comments!
-John
Had the same problem, it's likely to be the winding, check if there's a loose wire (I used a small paintbrush alternating up and down to find it). Thats assuming you have a open case motor, but it is repairable if you know someone who refurbs electric armatures or windings, if not then it's a replacement motor, but I would just return it, unless you can't live without this S4.
 
Last edited:


I had an Athearn Genesis motor with the same fault. I eventually opened it up, after replacing it and found a loose wire on the commutator segment of one pole. Solder had a dry joint.
 
You could try taking the motor apart and cleaning the brushes and commutator with brake clean or similar degreaser . After doing that check for sparking on the commutator when it is running. If there is excessive sparking , chances are one winding has opened up . A little grease or oil on the commutator will prevent proper brush contact and may cause dead spots. I did this to 2 of my 40 yr old locos and it solved the problem.
 
Thanks for all the replies!

Following the various ideas, I checked for loose wires, and any other faults at the magnets and windings...

I then flushed the commutator plates and brush faces with a small amount of isopropyl alcohol (ISA), let it evaporate, and tried running again.

Complete success! The loco now responds at a very low voltage, and runs smooth as silk. I can stop and re-start it with absolutely no hesitations.

Thanks for the suggestions, muchly appreciated!

-John
 




Affiliate Disclosure: We may receive a commision from some of the links and ads shown on this website (Learn More Here)

Back
Top