Steamer Color Issue

ModelRailroadForums.com is a free Model Railroad Discussion Forum and photo gallery. We cover all scales and sizes of model railroads. Online since 2002, it's one of the oldest and largest model railroad forums on the web. Whether you're a master model railroader or just getting started, you'll find something of interest here.


SpaceMouse

Fun Lover
I posted this on the "other" board, so pardon me if you saw it there.

When I first started, out my plan was to model Hogwart's. I created a bunch of engines and rolling stock. When my kids decided they no longer wanted to run trains, I gave up Hogwarts and moved West.

Now I've changed my time zone and two of the engines now fit in.

hogwartspower01.jpg


The engine on the right, my daughter's Hogwart's engine, is a IHC Premier 4-4-0, and is flat out the best running steam engine I've ever owned. I once timed it taking a 9" straight in 22 seconds with no jerking. Right now it has an el chepo MDC decoder and so I have very little control over the CVs, but I would add sound anyway.

hogwartspower02.jpg


The engine on the left, my son's Hogwart's engine, is an MDC 4-6-0 that I built from a kit. It is an okay runner with a lot of weight. I spent some time with it painting the gauges and adding an engineer and fireman.

hogwartspower03.jpg


HogEx02.jpg


Both have sentimental value and I would like them to have a place on the Rock Ridge and Train City II, as part of the Rock Ridge fleet in 1909.

But the problem (besides backdating issues) is obvious--they are red.

So what do I do? The red paint jobs are pretty good. I could leave it and slap Rock Ridge marks on them. Or I could re-paint them black, but each of them have 4-5 coats. More than likely, as far as quality paint jobs go, it will be downhill from here.

Suggestions? "It's your railroad." comments are not helpful. Is it even conceivable possible that a middle-sized road would have red engines in 1909? These would be the only two. The rest would be the more typical black.

Southern had green locos, right?
 
Chip, I would think if they mostly see service at the head of passenger trains, they could be part of the grand color scheme of the Rock Ridge. Frieght engines would be less inclined to be in bright colors. Put some decals on them and a bit of weathering in the right places and I think they would be fine! That's one of the nice things about freelance RRs, to a point almost anything goes. Oh yeah you probably want to do some period changhes on them.
 


Yeah I would give them some decals and some road grime and let them go . I'm sure back in 1909 there where some red engines running around !!
 
Chip, I would think if they mostly see service at the head of passenger trains, they could be part of the grand color scheme of the Rock Ridge. Frieght engines would be less inclined to be in bright colors. Put some decals on them and a bit of weathering in the right places and I think they would be fine! That's one of the nice things about freelance RRs, to a point almost anything goes. Oh yeah you probably want to do some period changhes on them.

Where can I get info about backdating them?
 




Affiliate Disclosure: We may receive a commision from some of the links and ads shown on this website (Learn More Here)

Back
Top