P2K GP38-2 Is NOT DCC Ready!!

ModelRailroadForums.com is a free Model Railroad Discussion Forum and photo gallery. We cover all scales and sizes of model railroads. Online since 2002, it's one of the oldest and largest model railroad forums on the web. Whether you're a master model railroader or just getting started, you'll find something of interest here.


macjet

Member
I'm sure the old timers here already know this but for the new guys like me here is the answer to a problem I came across this week. I installed four Digitraxx DH165LO's into four different P2K GP38-2's. The lights would work, the decoder would program, and the speed steps were there. But the things wouldn't budge an inch.

Here is the fix from Tony's Train Exchange (where I ordered my decoders):

Geroge B has discovered a problem with the Proto 2000 GP-38-2 that may damage decoder.

A number of our members have encountered a significant problem when installing plug-n-play type decoders in the new Lifelike Proto 2000 GP38-2 locos, just released. It appears that the lamps used by Lifelike to light the Number Boards are improperly wired to the connector plug at the factory which will result in damage to the decoder used if operated on DCC. The lamps are connected between the rails on one side and the output of the decoder on the other. While the decoder will seem to program properly - when the operator attempts to run on main power the unit will not respond and may have blown control in one direction - the number board lamps will also not operate.

My suggestion is to remove the lamps that light the numberboards, replace them with 12V 40ma lamps and connect them across the red & black track wires - they will be on all the time or use one of the functions if you want to turn them on and off. If your decoder supports 1 1/2 V lamps - you can use the ones that Lifelike supplies , when connecting to other functions otherwise you'll need to replace them with 12V.

George

I left these engines at the club to work on them later and I haven't rewired them yet nor do I know what if any damage was done to the decoders.

As a side note, there is a similar problem with the P2K GP/SD60's. That fix is available on digitraxx.com under "What decoder do I need?"
 
Interesting, my GP38-2's and SD60 did not have that problem. Something to keep in mind if others have problems though. Thanks for sharring.
 
If the decoders are damaged, don't throw them out yet. They may be repairable.

I had a metal bodied E5 with a dodgy motor and had two NCE decoders fail when the motor accidentally grounded. The MOSFET output ICs needed to be replaced (one on one if the decoders, both on the second one). The surface mount IC is around 3 or 4 bucks - got mine at Digikey.

If you are an electronics tech or know someone who is, it may be a cheap fix. Then again that was on NCE decoders - your mileage may vary.

Mark
 


I'm hoping that they still work. The lights, speed steps, addressing, etc was all working up to the point that we quite and I grabbed a club unit to run some trains. It will be awhile before I find out but I'll post results when I have them. Now I've got to make sure my two SD60's and one GP60 get put together correctly!
 
My Proto 2000 S1 said it was DCC ready...NOT!!! I blew a TCS decoder. After finding the fix on line all is well now. The only good thing is that Train Control System gave me a new decoder under warranty. Great service. It is just an expensive lesson to learn on what models are really DCC ready or could be.
Greg
 
my problem is like this but not exactly. It seems to program fine, however when i place it on the main the lights STAY ON but the thing wont move.
 
my problem is like this but not exactly. It seems to program fine, however when i place it on the main the lights STAY ON but the thing wont move.

Same problem as above. You've also got F0 turned on I believe. One of my 4 GP38's did this same thing.
 
Interesting, my GP38-2's and SD60 did not have that problem. Something to keep in mind if others have problems though. Thanks for sharring.

Thats wierd, I was told you pretty much had to replace the light w/a 12v. on my SD60's.

Have the decoders and new bulbs and have not got around to replacing/installing them. I bought some of the first SD60's when they came out. Is it possible they had later runs that added the lighted number boards which in turn is causing the shorts ???

This topic couldn't have been better timed.
 
I have had the same problem with a proto 2K GP38-2 and Digitrax DH165LO decoder. I can communicate with the decoder, but will not run. Has any fix worked?
 


I have had the same problem with a proto 2K GP38-2 and Digitrax DH165LO decoder. I can communicate with the decoder, but will not run. Has any fix worked?

The fix in the first post works. I just removed the bulbs instead of rewiring for the number boards as I don't ever plan on "night ops". Of my 6 GP38's all were incorrectly wired. Two of the decoders were blown and went back to Digitrax. Two worked even after being powered up incorrectly.

Another option would be to wire them to the function outputs. Just make sure that you use a resistor if you don't replace the factory 1.5V P2K bulbs. The F outputs are at track power.
 




Affiliate Disclosure: We may receive a commision from some of the links and ads shown on this website (Learn More Here)

Back
Top