New To Model RR

ModelRailroadForums.com is a free Model Railroad Discussion Forum and photo gallery. We cover all scales and sizes of model railroads. Online since 2002, it's one of the oldest and largest model railroad forums on the web. Whether you're a master model railroader or just getting started, you'll find something of interest here.


jeast

New Member
Hi my name is Jared im new here. Im looking to start a collection but dont know what scale would be best for me.
What I want in a model railroad.
1. Sound is very important to me.
2. Detail is also important to me.
3. A lot of extras like bulidings and a lot of trains available.
4. Low Price.
5. I have limited space but not a big issue.
 
HO nuff-said!

Has most extra items available, space is flexible, details are great, DCC w/ sound is perfect on many models, prices are affordable.

Its all in how much you want to spend. Don't be afraid to drop some extra bucks if you want perfect details, operation, and quality...as in anything, "You get what you pay for!"
 
I'd have to agree, HO fills that criteria best. If size (and to some degree budget) was not an issue O would be another option.

Mark
 


Hello and welcome to the forum !!!!!!! HO has a lot options , but nodays N scale has alot of equipment also !!!
 
There is no simple answer to your question. None of us responding here knows your circumstances well enough to be able to do much more than give you some ideas for consideration. Instead, you will have to contemplate which scale offers you the greatest chances of achieving your goals and preferences.

Intuitively, you understand that you can get more N into a given space than you can the larger scales. As stated above, N models and details are now more affordable and plentiful than they were, say, 15 years ago. But there's more to having more stuff in a given space....what if you can't really see it all that well? If you are nearing middle-age, your visual acuity has begun to slip. You'll need better glasses, or eyes, or a lot more light. What kind of light? Situated how? From directly above, from slightly behind the viewer and aimed toward the models in front of the viewer?

Then there is the ease of actually handling said items. Our mitts become less dextrous and sensitive over time. Try replacing a coupler on an N-Scale boxcar or engine. Not for me...not ever. Then there's the track laying in that scale, and the detailing and scenicking to get it looking half-ways decent. At the least you'll need very good eyes and youthful hands...under 50 for many of us.

I would pick a scale in seconds, though, and spend the lion's share of my time figuring out a track plan and a bench to support it that allows me access and handy wiring and trouble-shooting, plus the track plan that "works". A railroad works for revenue. None of them go around an oval...well, in some amusement parks they do, sure, but you catch my drift. So a realistic or operational track plan is going to keep you in the fun and interested far longer than an oval with a siding or two and some industrial spurs.

I hope that helps to orient you to the way I would approach the topic.

-Crandell
 
Welcome, Jared!
I agree, HO would fit your criteria best.
Once you decide the scale, then more questions will need to be answered, and you've hit the jackpot here. There are lots of very knowledgeable folk here.
 
Jared- Welcome to a very helpful forum.
Remember that the advice expessed here is worth every penny you will pay for it!:D
Some things to think about: where and when, gotta haves and gimmes?

What geographical area will you model? Rural Alabama or urban Chicago? Maine coastal bays or Arizona desert? Mountains or the Great Lakes region?

Which era of time? Today's bullet trains and intermodal freights? 1860's Civil War varied railroads with wood-burning engines and reconstruction/expansion of rail across America? The 1930's "Steam is King" and the beginning of diesel locomotives? Or the 1950's last gasp of steam power as diesel power carried fewer passenger trains and steam hauled a few freight extras.

I gotta have curves no larger than 22" radius due to space constraints limits the size and length of engines and freight/passenger cars. I gotta have a small freight station like the one in my hometown.

Can you gimme a girder bridge over the river and 1930's icehouse at the old JOLLY GREEN GIANT food plant?

Jared- by making a few decisions now, you can plan your time, economic resources and priorities to begin your layout.
Let us know how we can help!
Mikey
 
Hello and Welcome, Jared! I'll throw my hat into the 'HO' ring with the others.

One of our members, Chip (Space Mouse) has written a highly entertaining Beginners Guide To Layout Design. Lots of good insight, I even go back and re-read often myself even though my layout's been built for a few years!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Welcome to the forum Jared!

I would agree that probably your best choice given the conditions you stated in your post would be HO overall. On the other hand if sound is your biggest want. HO sound is still crap and very toy like. That little 3/4" speaker cannot create a believable sound for either diesel of steam. It is about an octave off. On the other hand I am a musician by profession and stuff like that bugs me. Find a Hobby Shop or someone that can fire up some HO Locos with sound and see what you think about it.

If that just doesn't make it for you, give a listen to O scale. It still is lacking for me, but certainly has it all over HO for sound.

Just my 2¢.
 
Since sound is so important I'll add my vote to HO scale. Adding sound decoders to HO locos is relatively simple. Also HO is the cheapest scale to build in and has the widest selection to choose from. Unless you're really cramped on space you should be able to work out a layout with decent capacity for scenery and running trains. You could also consider N-scale. It's about half the size of HO so you can fit more into a given space with it, the cost of corresponding parts (track, locos, rolling stock, etc) is generally the same as is the level of detail offered. The downsides to it are since you can fit more into a given space you'll end up spending more. Also sound is a bit more of a pain to stick into an n-scale loco than HO and the selection is a little bit smaller. Since you want to run alot of trains with sound I strongly recommend getting DCC as a control system, it costs more than conventional control methods but makes operation a whole lot simpler and enjoyable. Good luck and welcome.
 


Wow thank you all for your great advice and hospitality. I was thinking HO scale but just didnt know anything about them. I will have alot of thinking to do on a track setup and on which year trains to run.

Thank you all.
 
Hello, Jared, and welcome aboard. As others have stated, HO seems like it would be your best choice based on criteria. However, you'd better reevaluate#4 since #1 and #2 negate #4. Sound and detail does not equal low cost. A well detailed modern diesel with DCC and a good sound system averages anout $350. You can just about double that for steam. I'm not trying to discourage you, just let you know that buying well detailed, sound equipped models is a major commitment of funds. A lot of modelers don't work out a budget for what they want and end up with not having enough money for important items (like switches), whcih can be a major interest killer in model railroading.

Hi my name is Jared im new here. Im looking to start a collection but dont know what scale would be best for me.
What I want in a model railroad.
1. Sound is very important to me.
2. Detail is also important to me.
3. A lot of extras like bulidings and a lot of trains available.
4. Low Price.
5. I have limited space but not a big issue.
 




Affiliate Disclosure: We may receive a commision from some of the links and ads shown on this website (Learn More Here)

Back
Top