History of All Kinds

ModelRailroadForums.com is a free Model Railroad Discussion Forum and photo gallery. We cover all scales and sizes of model railroads. Online since 2002, it's one of the oldest and largest model railroad forums on the web. Whether you're a master model railroader or just getting started, you'll find something of interest here.


We forgot a BIG ONE> Mt St.Helens went Bada BOOM, on May 18, 1980

1779309299353.png
 


I am a Star Wars fan. Just a fan not a crazy but I had no real issue with Phantom Menace. Most of them were poorly scripted and the actors just above acceptable. But there was just something about the series that captivated the movie goers and I was one of those.
My biggest problem was the whole C3PO deal. The whole point of droids like R2D2 and C3PO is that there are thousands or 10s of thousands of them out there being a production model droid. Yet here in this movie we have Anikin building C3PO from scratch?? Huge blunder on their part, to me it ruins the entire effect of the series.

Yet then so many other things are forcibly contrived to match the later episodes. It doesn't flow. I had always thought Lucas had already written all nine before he started, but obviously not. Then with all the time between Return of the Jedi and Phantom Menace I thought it was painfully obvious that he hadn't thought too much about it in those intervening years either.
 
My biggest problem was the whole C3PO deal. The whole point of droids like R2D2 and C3PO is that there are thousands or 10s of thousands of them out there being a production model droid. Yet here in this movie we have Anikin building C3PO from scratch?? Huge blunder on their part, to me it ruins the entire effect of the series.

Yet then so many other things are forcibly contrived to match the later episodes. It doesn't flow. I had always thought Lucas had already written all nine before he started, but obviously not. Then with all the time between Return of the Jedi and Phantom Menace I thought it was painfully obvious that he hadn't thought too much about it in those intervening years either.
It’s all about the $$$
 


VMy biggest problem was the whole C3PO deal. The whole point of droids like R2D2 and C3PO is that there are thousands or 10s of thousands of them out there being a production model droid. Yet here in this movie we have Anikin building C3PO from scratch?? Huge blunder on their part, to me it ruins the entire effect of the series.

Yet then so many other things are forcibly contrived to match the later episodes. It doesn't flow. I had always thought Lucas had already written all nine before he started, but obviously not. Then with all the time between Return of the Jedi and Phantom Menace I thought it was painfully obvious that he hadn't thought too much about it in those intervening years either.
Well....maybe C3PO was a DIY kit. Sorta like one of the old "Heathkit" electronic kits from the 1950's and 60's.

But yeah, I get how revisionist history can kill off believability in the originals. RV History can kill them off almost from behind (timeline-wise) if they are "prequels."
--------------

Even in my own tiny little proto-freelanced model railroad universe it can be difficult--but also challenging--to fit "imaginary/conjured up" things with real-world things. That's part of the challenge of pulling the whole package together in a way that makes it believable...or at least somewhat palatable to the skeptics.

FWIW, I'm a skeptic too, and when the air goes out of the original "fanboy*" balloon, it's usually gone. Deflated forevermore for me too.
 

Today is Friday, May 22, 2026

The History of Today

1761 - In Philadelphia, the first life insurance policy was issued in the U.S.

1841 - Henry Kennedy received a patent for the first reclining chair.

1900 - The Associated Press was incorporated as a non-profit news cooperative in New York.

1985 - Pete Rose passed Hank Aaron as National League run scoring leader with 2,108.

1992 - Johnny Carson hosted NBC's "Tonight Show" for the last time. He had been host for 30 years
 
May 23, 1903

The first great American road trip
On this day in 1903, Horatio Nelson Jackson and Sewall Crocker embarked on the first transcontinental automobile trip. At the time there were few paved roads, questionable maps, no gas stations, no rest stops, and no fast food. The 5,600-mile journey—from San Francisco to New York City—took just over 63 days and required 800 gallons of gas.

1779541818490.png
 






Affiliate Disclosure: We may receive a commision from some of the links and ads shown on this website (Learn More Here)

Back
Top