Grab irons. Bend and make your own or buy them?


C

ChevelleSSguy

Member
They dont look very hard to make out of the proper gauge wire. .008 diameter I think for locomotives. However, they arent that expensive for a pack.

What do you guys do. Make and bend your own or just buy them?
 
If they are made in RTR, I use them. As you say, pretty cheap and saves some time. If there are none available already bent, I do bend my own. Grab irons are fairly simple, and I have several jigs I made using a piece of wood with brads for some of those oddly shaped stirrup steps. Locomotive handrails, especially the end ones on hood units, are another thing altogether. I've done it, but it ain't fun. :)
 
There are small jigs that can be purchased for bending grabs and some even come as a part of better craftsmen kits. However, these aren't generally suitable for making common drop grabs. And speaking as someone who has, on occasion, made his own, unless you intended to outfit dozens and dozens of pieces of rollingstock with grabs, I really don't regard the monetary savings in making your own as honestly worthwhile. It's a lot easier just to reach into the little bag and pull out a readi-formed one that you absolutely know is going to perfectly match the appearance/shape of every other one you attach.

Most hobbyists today are spending $150-$350 per locomotive and $20-$35 per freight car, so how can one seriously quible about the price of a package of grabs?

NYW&B
 
Last edited by a moderator:
At the price of today's stock, Grab irons, railings and such SHOULD be perfect!!!! And included INSTALLED on the piece. Companies want to charge more for what they call detail, they should cowboy up and make the car or engine detailed and RTR.

Bob
 
Grab irons are just as easy to buy them. Handrails sets on the other hand can be bent in about 10 minutes. All of these were bent using brass stock.

100_4911.jpg
 
NYW&B said:
Most hobbyists today are spending $150-$350 per locomotive and $20-$35 per freight car, so how can one seriously quible about the price of a package of grabs?

NYW&B
Click to expand...

This was my line of thinking when I began posting this. BLMA appears to have .008 sized grab irons in a pretty decent quality of packages.

http://www.blmamodels.com/cgi-bin/w...EcHA8CCAYEAwUECQkTEQAA&categories=01001-00010

The price you pay for the generous amount you get in the package you choose, either the 20 count or the 80 count. It really doesnt make much sense to attempt to make them yourself. Especially given your only spending pennies per locomotive to add grab irons with that kind of cost. Looks like its better to just buy them already made and ready to install.
 
wheeler1963 said:
Grab irons are just as easy to buy them. Handrails sets on the other hand can be bent in about 10 minutes. All of these were bent using brass stock.

100_4911.jpg
Click to expand...

Looks nice! Did you bend the vertical pieces as well? If so are the wrapped around the horizontal section? (similar to old metal athearn)

On another note, I purchased 18" drop grabs through Tichy and thought they were very reasonable for a bulk bag. Walthers number 293-3015. $3 for 100.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Some of my old engines no longer have grab iron sets or hand rails available. Fabricating my own is the best alternative. I've tried "bashing" other manufacturers' product to fit with limited success. Sometimes you gotta do what you gotta do.....

Bob
 
You must log in or register to reply here.



Back
Top