ModelRailroadForums.com is a free
Model Railroad Discussion Forum and
photo gallery. We cover all scales and sizes of model railroads. Online since 2002, it's one of the oldest and largest model railroad forums on the web. Whether you're a master model railroader or just getting started, you'll find something of interest here.
Hi,
To start I'm basically looking for a nice tank engine for my layout but searching for "tank engine" always gives you thomas produts. I also can only find those common 0-4-0 dockside switchers.
So my question is, does anyone make a good tank engine thats NOT those docksides OR model powers 0-4-0?
It could be saddle, side tank, w/e im just tired of only seeing those for HO.
It seems like N scale has more of a range ???
Something like the 0-4-0 tea kettle would be nice, just something DIFFERENT.
-Joe
Joe, Model Power and Life-Like produce the only two 0-4-0 plastic tank engines in HO. There were a few 0-4-0 tank engines produced in brass but I haven't seen any in years. The problem is that there were never very many 0-4-0 tanks engines ever produced by prototype manufacturers so they were never very popular with modelers. If it hadn't been for Varney making the original B&O Docksider (which is the same model now sold by Life-Like) there probably wouldn't be any of these tank engines at all in HO. The Docksider was used in a lot of train sets as a cheap steam engine and that's what kept it alive all this time. Are you looking for a particular prototype? The Docksider is a good starting point for kitbashing.
Model Power has an 0-6-0 in their Mantua Classics line. I picked up one cheap at Hobby Lobby a few years ago and it's a fine runner. It does have a few visual annoyances that can probably be fixed with a little bit of effort.
http://store.modelpower.com/index.asp?PageAction=VIEWCATS&Category=111
Man, talk about the Wayback Machine -- I had one of the originals of this model when I was a kid back in about 1957... Looks like the current model still has the electrical pickup on the middle driver. I may have to get one just for the nostalgia value.
Yup! The pickup on the middle driver is one of those "visual annoyances".
Spectrum made a very excellent 0-6-0 that is a "tanker". They are very smooth runners and fairly good pullers for their size.
IIRC its currently not in the catalog, but one can be had on E-bay fairly easily.
Hmmmm.
Sorry I like that spectrum but I'm not looking for such an expensive modeler. Im very frugal.
So theres not many tank engines huh? Shoulda gone european. They have nice variety.
Maybe I some of you are mistaken. It doesn't HAVE to be an 0-4-0. Actually if anyone makes 0-4-2's that would be great.
There's a greater variety of tank engines available in N scale specifically because some of them were adapted from European designs. If you're really interested in tank engines, I suggest you consider switching to N scale. The Model Power and Life-Like tank engines are the only two inexpensive tank engines of any wheel arrangement available in HO.
No thanks N scale is too small. What about small diesels?
Are there any good ones?
No thanks N scale is too small. What about small diesels?
Are there any good ones?
Again Spectrums are good ones to look at for these. They make a 44 and 70 ton diesel.
MDC has a model of a very early diesel, but I don't know if it has been re-released since Horizon bought them.
I'd check with the various internet shops and E-bay to get the best price.
I'll agree wholeheartedly with CJ on a Bachman Spectrum 44 or 70 tonner. Nice engines and you can get them with DCC already installed for less than $45 on e-bay. There are also some small critters like the Tyco/Mantua Plymouth and even some older Athearn Hustlers if you keep looking on e-bay. There are probably more that I've forgotten but there's a way better selection of small diesels in HO than small steam.
Affiliate Disclosure: We may receive a commision from some of the links and ads shown on this website
(Learn More Here)
