dcc vs dc

ModelRailroadForums.com is a free Model Railroad Discussion Forum and photo gallery. We cover all scales and sizes of model railroads. Online since 2002, it's one of the oldest and largest model railroad forums on the web. Whether you're a master model railroader or just getting started, you'll find something of interest here.


phantomphuler

New Member
i'm sure someone can help me. i have an old layout that i havent changed in a long time. i want to buy a new loco but dcc vs dc confuses me. anthearn makes the ready to roll locos that say dcc ready. can i run these on my old dc setup?
 
DCC ready means you can use it on a DC layout. In order for a DCC ready loco to be DCC, it requires a decoder.

DCC equipped or decoder equipped you can't use on a DC layout.
 
Actually you can use a DCC equipped engine on a DC layout. There is a programming feature in the decoder that passes DC through to the motor if the decoder senses it - most decoders I know of have this feature. AFAIK, it is programmed as active by default so you are good to go.

Mark
 


Yes, virtually all modern decoders are dual mode. They are meant to receive the signal overlay on a square wave AC signal, but they will accept and use DC automatically as they arrive from the factory. You can alter CV 29 to whichever setting your decoder manufacturer says will limit the decoder to AC operations (sensitivity) only.

"DCC-ready" does not translate to a standardized meaning from manufacturer to manufacturer. It is meant to suggest to the buyer that the engine is simple to convert to DCC operation by installing a decoder, but that is not true in the same way from engine to engine. Some require more work. Some have a pin connector that is not standard, for example.

To the asker, if you buy a "DCC-ready" engine, you will indeed by able to run it on your DC system without any modifications or caveats. This is so because it is not DCC, but is only DC capable when you get it, as the first responder has said. You must purchase and supply an appropriate decoder for that model, install it properly and safely, and then you can still use it on your DC layout, but you won't be able to modify motor performance characteristics via programming CVs. You can only do that with a DCC system.
 
I'de strongly recommend getting February's issue of model railroader. They are doing a piece on constructing a shelf layout. they install the wiring in this issue. This site has helped me understand DCC so much better then just figuring it out by myself. But this article makes it so easy to understand and soooooo simple to do. Unless they skipped alot of things and just made it look alot easier.
 




Affiliate Disclosure: We may receive a commision from some of the links and ads shown on this website (Learn More Here)

Back
Top