Can an oval layout bring as much fun and enjoyment like a club layout?

ModelRailroadForums.com is a free Model Railroad Discussion Forum and photo gallery. We cover all scales and sizes of model railroads. Online since 2002, it's one of the oldest and largest model railroad forums on the web. Whether you're a master model railroader or just getting started, you'll find something of interest here.


homersimpsonlikestrains

homersimpsonlikestrains

Active Member
Can a humble oval layout bring as much fun and enjoyment like a club layout?

For example, what if a person is on a budget, has limited space and is unable to have a permanent and massive layout? Can an oval layout, with one turnout, a station, a few road crossings, trees, bridge, etc., and maybe even DCC sound/Lionchief, be as much fun as a massive club layout? Or are oval layouts almost ALWAYS destined to quickly become boring right away?

What are your thoughts?
 
Last edited:
It depends on what your idea of fun is. If you are into complex switching problems, and don't care that much about building a small layout, then the answer is "no". On the other hand, if you would like to lay track, create scenery, and run a train or two, then a small layout can be a lot of fun for quite a while. It also depends on what scale you are planning to use. Certainly, there are advantages to belonging to a club, including the fellowship with the members. But why limit yourself to one or the other. You can have your own layout, and join a club. And why limit yourself to just an oval and one turnout? There are a plethora of small layout designs. Buy a book on small track plans.

The important thing is to get started. You never know when you might be able to expand your layout at some future date. In the meantime, just have fun, and don't hesitate to ask questions here.
 
homersimpsonlikestrains said:
Can a humble oval layout bring as much fun and enjoyment like a club layout?

For example, what if a person is on a budget, has limited space and is unable to have a permanent and massive layout? Can an oval layout, with one turnout, a station, a few road crossings, trees, bridge, etc., and maybe even DCC sound/Lionchief, be as much fun as a massive club layout? Or are oval layouts almost ALWAYS destined to quickly become boring right away?

What are your thoughts?
Click to expand...
Like Trailrider said, It depends what fun is for you. For some, its just the modeling that is the real fun part, and the running trains is just a bonus. For me, I just like to break out the trains and do a bit of running sometimes, so the loop doesn't bother me. But I think anyone who likes running loops, would probly agree that a club layout is just as much (Or more) fun.
 


An oval of track on a 4x8 sheet of plywood would bore me to tears in 3 minutes. That same oval with a few short spurs, well made structures, and scenery with people and vehicles might last me 30 minutes or so.

I've never seen a club layout in person, but I did see a private layout in '17 that was so large you couldn't see all of it without going from room to room. The only disadvantage of a layout that enormous is waiting for the trains to come back so you can see them if you don't follow them around.

I would like to add more to my 12x14 layout, but I'm pretty satisfied with it. Any smaller and I would likely be bored. The roundy-round effect is minimized with tunnels and hidden sections of the layout so the trains look like they are coming and going instead of traveling in an endless loop.
 
homersimpsonlikestrains said:
Can a humble oval layout bring as much fun and enjoyment like a club layout?
Click to expand...
Absolutely!
trailrider said:
It depends on what your idea of fun is.
Click to expand...
But it will not be for everybody.

There are nearly as many ways to enjoy this hobby as there are hobbyists in it.

"To each his own"

What works for one person might not work for another, and that’s perfectly okay.

As a Lionel fan I chose this as my only forum because of the number of members who have respect for individuality and personal choice.
 
There's an old Peruvian aphorism that goes, 'Quando hay hambre, no hay pan duro.' When you're hungry, there's no hard bread. Another way of putting it, 'Dance with the girl you brung.' At least at first, and sometimes by force for an entire hobby life, even a simple switching layout, no oval, will have to suffice. I'm thinking that when I go into 'the home' in 15 years (Deo volente), I expect the missus will have passed, and I'll have the internet and two or three locomotives and some cars left, plus my DCC controller. It will have to be a shelf layout tucked into a corner, but I'll have that layout and enjoy it to bits. Maybe even have a coupla structures, a fence, three trees...who knows.

My point is each of us must define what we need out of the hobby, and then do our most assiduous to achieve it. It may not last, and early in our hobby we tend to evolve quickly to new interests or passions. For me it was photography, and it was then, as I had been warned by other hobby photogs, that you learn how bad your scenery and positioning are. Oh boy! My hobby improved through photography.

Oh, and although not technically an oval, my second layout, the one I built after retirement, was pretty much an oval. The first layout, which Santa brung five decades earlier, was just an oval on ply. Loved it!

[Edited to correct eyeroller typo]
 
Last edited:
Maybe consider either TTrak modules or something like this that fits into the area you have, it's what I am doing.
 

Attachments

  • Gorre Daphetid track plan.png
    Gorre Daphetid track plan.png
    1.4 MB · Views: 59


I don’t really think you can compare a simple oval layout with a club layout.
A better comparison would be a simple oval layout with a similar size layout.
If just watching a train run is your enjoyment then maybe yes an oval with great scenery would be fun!
If you’re into switching then no you’ll be bored in no time.
Now a simple oval with maybe a siding or a spur might just keep you happy and busy enough.

Here’s a great example of an oval layout that a friend of mine built that another friend now owns.
By the way, this is N scale and is double sided.


IMG_1750.jpeg

IMG_1749.jpeg
 
In my opinion, a small layout with no switching or spurs becomes very boring quite quickly. But that same layout with a few spurs and a small switchyard can become much more entertaining. Certain tasks, as simple as changing the order of the cars in a train by switching (not by picking them up) adds to the fun in a layout. Moving full coal cars to the power plant or logs to the sawmill are other examples. These areas can be added to a small layout pretty easily and will add hours of enjoyment to your layout.
 
If you've got enough room for a 4x8 (or even 3x6) oval, you've got enough room for not just one but several turnouts, and that means enough room for operation. If you can split that plywood sheet into strips 1' to 2' deep, you can have a shelf layout that occupies 2 or 3 walls of a room. That's enough layout to keep you entertained with operation and construction for quite a while. If you're on a budget, start with one 8' section and work your way around the room as time & budget allows! The 2 images below show an example, which was the starting point for my own around-the-room layout--10 square feet, an L-shaped 3x6 foot layout that includes a runaround track, a 3 track yard and 4 industries--a total of 7 turnouts. A locomotive can switch between the yard and industries using a "car card" or "switch list" operating scheme, the same way that big club layouts do it. When you finish the first section--start the next one and expand your operation, while in the same physical footprint as your simple loop.

(Note: all this assumes HO--but the same principle applies to N scale, in even less space.)


20220326_205554.jpg

20220326_205556.jpg
 
AirbrushNo5 said:
There used to be an old building in my hometown that had Cold Storage painted on the brick…
I liked the concept of a wall/shelf layout..but I was too far committed to a 52” x 8’ rectangle to go back
Click to expand...

The "Cold Storage" building is connected by a conveyor over the roadway to the Libby McNeill & Libby cannery, which was a later expansion of the layout in the photo above, along with a 6' single ended classification yard (which later became a 10' double ended classification yard) as the layout grew and grew around the perimeter of my layout room--each section is 6' or less (to fit in the back of my station wagon) and designed to be relocated if necessary (I have moved twice since I started building the layout, which, while not exactly painless, is simpler than demolishing & rebuilding a permanent layout.)
20220306_204728.jpg
 
Of course it can. Contrary to what the magazines would have you believe not every layout needs to be a basement clogger and operation doesn't need 20 or 30 people. to be fun. For example Tony Thompson's SP layout seems like a good ol' 4x8 only with the bottom rounded and at the top some wings added to give the layout a sort of T shape.

Also operation can be a simple one man show as Lance Mindheim points out in a lot of the articles on his blog. Another thing he emphasizes in his articles is slow deliberate pace for operations rather than pretending you're a UPS driver and way behind. https://lancemindheim.com/model-railroad-blog/
 
If you build it, you'll find out. The simple oval might have worked back in childhood, but even then i would rearrange tracks after a while. That and being able to see big time real railroads at work had a rather inspiring effect, where i wanted to reproduce even just a small piece of operation just like in prototype. I have an oval in one of my rooms, but it's on the larger size with 35" curves on the main line, plus a station, a few sidings and an engine house. My priorities are different though, since my main goal is to test newly built locomotives and picture opportunities.
 


I have had HO scale trains since 12 years old. Did have a L shaped layout in my parents basement for a while.
Then for decades it was just set up around the Christmas Tree each year.
A couple of years ago, I made a 4x8 folding table that I can put up against my Shop machinery until each year I and the Grand Kids build a
NEW Layout on in December.
Every Year it is a NEW plan.
They add home made buildings which requires different sidings. And it is a Double Oval. One train runs continuously on on, and the inner track is for freight movements etc.
So, it doesn't get boring as trains are running as it gets built up. Then come January, I take it down and reclaim the shop bay for my Big Boy Projects.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.




Affiliate Disclosure: We may receive a commision from some of the links and ads shown on this website (Learn More Here)

Back
Top